Save Ely library from demolition

Letter to Cardiff council ..
I have seen the Notices saying you propose to demolish the notable Ely Library building and find that the public is supposed to ask you for further information. I see none in the planning application. Could you please provide any assessment the Communities section have made of the suitability of the building for alternative uses, and describe what alternative community uses you have considered? If you have looked into marketing the building and site, please also give details. Could you also provide an estimate of the cost of demolition and clearance of the site as you propose?

More info here Demolition of Ely Library 14/01057/DCO

Alternative uses for the existing buildings were not considered as this would not deliver the capital value or the amount of additional housing that would be achieved by clearing the site for development.

Hayley Morgan Regeneration Officer | Swyddog Adfywio City of Cardiff 

Ely Library to be demolished against wishes of the community and common sense

Ely Library to be demolished against wishes of the community and common sense

Just noticed...thanks to my local Councillor for telling me  NOT
Cardiff Council application to DEMOLISH the most attractive building in ELY 
more about Ely Library here 

At: ELY LIBRARY, 8 GRAND AVENUE, 
ELY, CARDIFF, CF5 4BL

Ely Library that the Cardiff Labour plan to demolish 

14/01057/DCO Application for 
Demolition
 Expected 
Decision DEL
Received: 24/04/2014 Ward: ELY
Case Officer: Martyn Rees
Applicant: Cardiff Council, County Hall, 
Atlantic Wharf, Cardiff
Agents: Cardiff Council Infrastructure 
Design and Construction Management, 
County Hall, Atlantic Wharf, Cardiff 
Proposal: DEMOLITION OF LIBRARY


How can Regeneration Officer agree to the demolition of the best building in Ely? 

A 'library' is to be crammed in the Ugly HUB with other
services Note the flat roofed garish coloured play porch
climbing frame  and special garish infantile letters to remove 

Rees, June 
From: Rees, Martyn 
Sent: 07 May 2014 15:17 
To: Rees, June 
Subject: FW: Ely Library and Housing Office 
  
As discussed, here is a summary of what is proposed 
following demolition:- Site will be top 
soiled and seeded then either secured with fencing 
and gates or remain open 
with bollards – subject to community consultation. 

I can confirm that the demolition notices were installed in 
the locality on 25th April 2014 and are 
being checked for the 4 week period and will be reinstalled as necessary. 

On reviewing the notices there is no contact details required / input on the notices for people to 
comment on. However the posters advising of the closure, demolition and redevelopment are 
visible in the library window as well as being on display in the library and housing office therefore 
anyone querying the notices are likely to be be the service users and would enquire within these 
buildings and be given our contact details. These posters have been on display since Thur 10th 
April and will remain in situ until closure at end of June. We have not had any queries to date. 

I hope this helps. 

Kind regards, 
Hayley Morgan 
Regeneration Officer | Swyddog Adfywio 
Cardiff Council |Cyngor Caerdydd 
Housing Development & Enabling |Datblygu Tai a Galluogi 
Housing & Communities |Tai a Chymunedau 
Willcox House |Ty Willcox 
PO Box 410, Cardiff, CF11 1FT |Blwch SP 410, Caerdydd, CF11 1FT 
Tel |Ffôn: 029 20 53 7359 (Internal |Estyniad 37359) 

14/01056/DCO Application for Demolition Expected Decision DEL

Received: 24/04/2014 Ward: ELY
Case Officer: Martyn Rees
Applicant: Cardiff Council, County Hall, Atlantic Wharf, Cardiff

Agents: Cardiff Council Infrastructure Design and Construction Management, County Hall, 
Atlantic Wharf, CardiffProposal: DEMOLITION OF HOUSING OFFICE

Ely Library Cardiff in PEVSNER ARCHITECTURAL GUIDES GLAMORGAN

 Ely Library gets a mention in the prestigious PEVSNER ARCHITECTURAL GUIDES GLAMORGAN

 

JOHN  NORMAN

 " A jolly little building,single storeyed, of red brick,under a hipped roof with glazed lantern. Towards the road,doorway between stout twin columns of brick and semicircular windows. The intention was to reflect the materials of the Resurrection church and the motifs of the neighbouring housing, but Soane's " barn a la Paestum " and even the Post Modernism of John Outram seem also to have been in mind. Inside, benches below the windows, and four more portly columns, their surfaces marbled, defining the top-lit space."

How could Ely Cllr Russell Goodway even contemplate demolishing this gem? maybe because he doesnt live here?

Write to him "Goodway, Russell (Cllr)"  R.V.Goodway@cardiff.gov.uk

Or the other Ely Councillors  Susan Goddard  - SGoddard@cardiff.gov.uk 

Cllr Jim Murphy - Jim.Murphy@cardiff.gov.uk 

Or write to Caerau Cllr Peter Bradbury Peter.Bradbury@cardiff.gov.uk

Save Ely Lbrary

Jasmine Centre with leaky roof and poor energy rating 

This is the Jasmine Centre that is now to house the reduced library service We called for this decision to be deferred. 
This proposal should be deferred until

1.    A proper assessment of the Jasmine Centre fitness for purpose including a building structure and sustainability report has been prepared.

Beautiful Ely library Featured in Glamorgan
(Pevsner Architectural Guides: Buildings of Wales)

to be demolished and services halved in

move to ugly leaky Jasmine centre ugly 

2.    An accessibility report prepared with vulnerable groups input.

3.    Cabinet members visit the site

4.    The hasty proposal to demolish the library ‘as soon as reasonably practicable’ should be suspended.

The existing purpose built Ely library was Good news for Ely Cardiff in 1976 on the site of the previous library but bad news as civic pride goes down the pan  in 2013 as it is destined for closure and demolition and a runt of a library shoe horned into the ugly Jasmine centre. Aspirations towards a garden village finally stamped out. Ely library was was designed by the staff and students of the Welsh School of architecture led by Prof Mike Harries in 1986 described in Punch at the time as an 'economic little gem' and designed to meet the needs of the community. The library is located in the closest Ely has to a central place and location to interact and is a building of merit and visually attractive. More info here http://saveelylibrary.blogspot.co.uk/ 
https://www.facebook.com/SaveElyLibrary

It is preposterous to suggest shoehorning in so many services into a inadequate building

Is the Jasmine Centre fit for purpose as a ‘hub’?

The Jasmine centre has a leaky corrugated metal roof and costly poor energy performance

Computer rooms in the Jasmine Centre have serious over-heating in the summer sun – the mobile fans used were costly and unsafe, unsuitable for use by many elderly and disabled people.  A potentially expensive system to improve ventilation in warm weather has been recommended -  go here 

Recent energy assessment report (July 2013) found only average energy performance and pointed up many deficiencies, recommending expert studies. It recommended a potentially expensive system to improve ventilation in warm weather.

There has been no assessment of the Building structure and integrity
For more  information go here

List Ely Library

Work has begun to get this building listed We want this building listed.  

Ely library - Good news for Ely Cardiff in 1976 but bad news as civic pride goes down the pan  in 2013 as it is destined for closure and demolition and a runt of a library shoe horned into the ugly Jasmine centre.

This was designed by the ataff and students of the Welsh School; of architecture led by Prof Mike Harries in 1986 described in Punch at the time as an 'economic little gem'  .  

Mike Harries outside the library he designed

Library Budget Outturn 2012/13

Title: Policy Review & Performance Scrutiny Committee 

---

Cardiff Council have found funds for other libraries. 
Description: Policy Review & Performance Scrutiny Committee 

• Budget Outturn 2012/13 (701k)

Location: Ferrier Hall, City Hall
Date: 09/07/2013
Start: 04:30 PM

Libraries
The Radyr library refurbishment scheme was completed at a total cost of
£565,000 and the library reopened in June. In respect of the Central library,
internal glass panels received a specialist coating in order to comply with
health and safety requirements, with works to the entrance door to be
completed early in 2013/14.
Whilst an application to WG in 2012/13 for £100,000 of grant funding towards
works at Canton Library was unsuccessful, grant of £120,000 has been
awarded for 2013/14. The scheme, expected to cost £700,000, has been
delayed whilst options for service delivery are considered as part of the Hub
proposals. A start on site is expected in July 2013.

Cardiff Council are going to close and demolish your library

Save Ely Library from demolition and closure. The consultation by Cardiff council on a 'community Hub'  doesn't make it clear that the Ely library is to close and moved to the greatly inferior Jasmine centre.

Ely library building is beautiful and inspirational and should be kept. It was designed by Mike Harries then director of the BSc course in architectural studies at the Welsh school of architecture at UWIST and delighted to work in Ely with . the staff and students of the Welsh School of architecture 

It was opened to great acclaim in 1986.  It replaced the old wooden library opened in 1938. It was described at the time as an 'economic little gem that is just right for its situation’.  

 Labour Cardiff Council want to create a ‘community hub’ which means moving services such as housing and benefit advice, library services, advice for job seekers, opportunities for learning. They suggest that the services of partners such as Citizen Advice and Want to Work and the police could also be included in the Hub. This means they could close the present hosing office in Grand Ave next to the library and make money after demolishing them both by selling the site.

The only and last question in the ‘consultation’ about this says services WILL be located in the Jasmine centre  and asks if you agree?

The Jasmine centre has already got problems with car parking and Treseder Way a quiet road and park behind will become a busy highway.

People in Splott are fighting a similar cuts plan to amalgamate services in a ‘hub’

Find  Save Ely Library  on Facebook Community hubs = cuts